How should you feel about the budget

← Homepage

WHEN you open up a Budget you want to see something that will help Australia. You want to see a Budget that is fair, one that is smart and bold.

So, you want to know how you should feel about this Budget? You should feel suspicious.

Its a jobs and growth budget that leaves the unemployment rate more or less untouched.

Its all about the government spending less, while spending actually goes up.

Its a budget that has some very good things in it But it also has some things that make you go hmmmm.


The 2016-17 Budget comes with four brochures explaining it. Each one has the words JOBS & GROWTH stamped on the front in big capital letters.

So youd expect the forecasts in the Budget to show an employment miracle. A big nine-to-five festival for all of us. The reality is rather different.

Unemployment is basically flatlining. Unemployment is now 5.7 per cent (seasonally adjusted, according to the most recent data). This Budget forecasts that number to fall slightly to 5.5 per cent next year (hurray!) and then stop falling so its 5.5 per cent in the year after (hrmph!).

And jobs growth is actually forecast to be slower in the future than it is now. It goes from 2 per cent growth this year to 1.75 per cent in the Budget years.

So the 0.2 percentage point improvement in the unemployment rate is all we get to last for the next two years, apparently. So is all that jobs talk worth it? Im suspicious.


The suspicious-est (not a word but it should be) part of this Budget is the way the government just keeps on taking more money from the economy. Right now it is taking just under 24 per cent of GDP each year.

But in a few years that will have risen to over 25 per cent. An extra $90 billion a year.

Thats fine. Its probably very smart. But that fact is confusing if you try to think about it and listen to the Treasurer at the same time.

He keeps talking about how Australia should keep spending under control. He talks about leaving money in your pocket, instead of taking it for the governments pocket. He keeps talking about living within our means.

Then he sits back to watch the governments means increase so we can live within them. Its a clever trick. See how the blue line (receipts, i.e. mainly tax) is expected to rise above its long-term average?


This Budget has some moments that look a bit dubious. But it also contains some fine, upstanding, young ideas I really should mention.

Shout-outs to removing tax breaks on the wealthiest peoples superannuation. And kudos for making multinational companies pay billions more in tax.

But even as it takes these commendable steps, the Budget is leaning ever harder on cigarette smokers to fund the government and is trying to get everyone to focus on a jobs program for young people that is smaller and cheaper than Work for the Dole. Which it very quietly slashed.

So, the Budget is a mix of great ideas and things that look more like cheap magic tricks. Are the good parts enough to turn round the economy where it matters to the rest of us? On that, youre within your rights to go: hmmm.

Jason Murphy is an economist. He publishes the blog Thomas The Think Engine. Follow him on Twitter @jasemurphy.

READ MORE: Budget 2016 winners and losers

We have put together a five minute survey so you can shape what stories you want to focus on in the lead up to the election.